Mental Illness

Families Speak Out on the Harms of ECT: A Call for Reassessment

A recently published study sheds light on the experiences of family members and friends regarding Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT), revealing widespread concerns about its negative impacts. The research indicates that a significant number of respondents witnessed a diminished quality of life in their loved ones post-ECT, alongside persistent issues with memory and cognition. Contrary to the intended therapeutic effects, many reported no improvement in symptoms, and some even observed a worsening condition. This comprehensive study underscores the need for a critical re-evaluation of ECT practices, particularly concerning patient well-being and the process of informed consent.

The Impact of Electroconvulsive Therapy: A Closer Look at Family Perspectives

In a groundbreaking article featured in Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, and Practice, led by independent scholar Christopher Harrop and co-authored by Dr. John Read from the University of East London, compelling findings emerged from a global survey concerning Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT). This study, conducted in 2026, gathered responses from 286 participants, predominantly from the United States (37%) and the United Kingdom (28%), who were friends or relatives of ECT recipients. The demographic data revealed that the majority of ECT recipients were white (89%) and female (68%), with daughters (19.4%), mothers (14.8%), and sisters (10.6%) being the most frequent respondents.

The survey's results painted a stark picture of the perceived harms of ECT. A staggering 60.1% of respondents reported that ECT was “not at all helpful,” while 80.9% believed it was harmful to some extent. Alarmingly, 42.4% indicated that the treated problems worsened, and 12.5% saw no change, meaning over half of the participants observed no improvement in their loved ones' symptoms. Furthermore, 61% noted a negative effect on their loved one's overall quality of life, compared to only 32.3% who saw improvement.

Memory loss was a dominant concern, with 60.7% reporting recent memory impairment and 73.3% experiencing issues with pre-ECT memories. Beyond memory, a wide array of adverse effects were frequently cited by over half of the respondents, including difficulty concentrating (79.1%), emotional blunting (72.6%), fatigue (73.3%), loss of independence (71.5%), relationship problems (70.2%), and difficulty with daily tasks such as driving, reading, and cooking. A troubling 34.2% suspected brain damage, and nearly half (47.7%) were unsure, while only 18.1% believed there was no brain damage.

The issue of consent was particularly contentious. While 47.1% stated their loved one consented voluntarily, 31.7% reported consent given under pressure, and 21.3% described the treatment as involuntary. This raises serious questions about ethical practices and patient autonomy within the mental health system. Participants expressed deep emotional distress, guilt, and a profound loss of faith in the medical community, with one family member describing the experience as 'terrifying' and another feeling they 'let her down' by not preventing the treatment.

The study acknowledges several limitations, such as potential recruitment bias due to the survey's distribution through channels critical of ECT, reliance on secondhand accounts and memory, and the exclusion of non-English speakers. Despite these, the consistent and overwhelming negative feedback from families provides a powerful argument against the current application of ECT.

This study serves as a poignant reminder that while medical interventions aim to alleviate suffering, their impact on patients and their families can be profoundly complex and, at times, devastating. The overwhelming reports of harm, particularly memory loss and decreased quality of life, alongside issues of consent, underscore an urgent need for greater transparency, more robust patient advocacy, and a re-evaluation of ECT's role in mental health treatment. It encourages the medical community to listen more attentively to the voices of those directly affected and to prioritize ethical considerations and holistic well-being over potentially harmful procedures. Moving forward, the mental health system must strive to offer treatments that truly heal, rather than inadvertently causing further suffering and despair.

Subtle Everyday Changes May Signal Early Alzheimer's Risk

For many older individuals, daily life is structured around established routines, encompassing activities from meal preparation to financial management and medication adherence. While these tasks are often performed with ease, some individuals may begin to experience minor, yet persistent, disruptions that can be easily dismissed as normal aspects of aging or a consequence of a busy lifestyle. These seemingly insignificant struggles, such as occasionally forgetting a grocery item or misplacing personal belongings, can sometimes be early indicators of more profound underlying issues.

Functional independence, which encompasses the complex interplay of memory, coordination, planning, and attention necessary for navigating daily life, serves as a crucial metric for evaluating well-being. Although clinical professionals have long recognized that a decline in functional independence is a hallmark of dementia, it is less commonly understood that such changes can manifest years prior to a formal diagnosis. These early functional alterations, even in the absence of overt memory problems, may suggest that the brain is at an increased risk of cognitive decline. Recent studies have highlighted the significance of persistent difficulties in daily activities—such as cooking, shopping, or driving—as a predictor of developing Alzheimer's disease, distinguishing them from temporary or sporadic lapses that do not carry the same prognostic weight. These enduring impairments have even been correlated with biological markers of the disease found in spinal fluid, preceding noticeable memory deterioration.

Observing these changes, particularly by family members who regularly interact with older adults, can be pivotal. They might notice a loved one struggling with once-familiar schedules, repeatedly checking routine processes, or avoiding previously enjoyed activities. This early recognition offers an opportunity for prompt evaluation, support, and proactive planning. Furthermore, these findings advocate for the integration of functional assessments into routine healthcare, alongside traditional cognitive screening tools. Unlike standard cognitive tests that can be influenced by linguistic, educational, or cultural factors, evaluating real-life functional abilities provides a practical and more universally applicable method for early detection. This approach allows for interventions like simplifying routines, using reminders, or providing assistance with complex tasks, which can help maintain independence and serve as early preventative measures. Ultimately, a greater emphasis on these subtle, persistent functional changes can significantly enhance our ability to understand and address cognitive health in the aging population, paving the way for improved care and quality of life.

By vigilantly observing and understanding the subtle functional shifts in daily life, we gain a crucial advantage in the early detection and management of cognitive decline, potentially altering the trajectory of aging and promoting better brain health for all. Engaging in research, such as the Canadian CAN-PROTECT and BAMBI studies, offers individuals an impactful way to contribute to this vital field, helping to advance our collective understanding and improve future interventions.

See More

Tabletop RPGs Boost Self-Concept: A 'Drama Therapy in the Wild' for Identity Growth

Recent research indicates that the immersive narratives and character connections fostered in tabletop role-playing games (TRPGs) can profoundly influence an individual's sense of self. These engaging experiences are not merely entertainment but serve as a unique form of "drama therapy in the wild," empowering players to explore alternative identities and address personal struggles within a safe and supportive social context. The study highlights how deep emotional bonds with fictional characters translate into tangible psychological benefits, offering a novel avenue for enhancing self-esteem and navigating identity challenges.

This study, led by Jeffrey G. Snodgrass, demonstrates that the informal character creation and role-playing within TRPGs mirror clinical therapeutic processes, allowing individuals to project themselves into imaginative scenarios. By embodying diverse characters and confronting fictional obstacles, players develop a stronger sense of self, increased self-efficacy, and greater compassion for themselves and others. The research also reveals that the long-term, collaborative nature of these games contributes to enduring friendships and a profound sense of belonging, further bolstering psychological well-being. The findings underscore the importance of fostering inclusive and supportive gaming environments to maximize these therapeutic gains, particularly for individuals exploring complex aspects of their identity.

The Therapeutic Power of Fictional Bonds

A recent academic publication in the journal Transcultural Psychiatry presents compelling evidence that individuals who immerse themselves in the creation and development of fictional characters within tabletop role-playing games experience notable enhancements in their personal identity. This investigation suggests that integrating these interactive storytelling formats into clinical practices could provide a potent means for patients to cultivate self-worth and work through personal difficulties. The psychological advantages derived from these activities are most consistently observed when the gaming setting offers a secure and encouraging social atmosphere.

Professor Jeffrey G. Snodgrass from Colorado State University's Department of Anthropology and Geography, a distinguished researcher known for his work on the intersection of gaming and well-being, spearheaded this project. Snodgrass's prior research, including his book The Avatar Faculty: Ecstatic Transformations in Religion and Video Games, laid the groundwork for examining the deep connections players form with their game avatars and fellow participants. Inspired by principles of drama therapy, the research team aimed to understand whether the imaginative role-playing inherent in TRPGs could replicate therapeutic outcomes, specifically focusing on how exploring diverse identities through characters might bolster a player's self-concept and address underlying emotional conflicts. The study utilized a mixed-methods approach, combining surveys from 149 North American gamers with in-depth interviews of 54 enthusiasts, primarily focusing on tabletop role-playing game participants.

Character Engagement and Self-Discovery

The research findings illustrate a strong correlation between the nature of a player's relationship with their character and the psychological benefits gained. Participants who perceived their characters as integral extensions of themselves or as distinct, independent personalities reported significantly greater improvements in their overall self-concept, a stark contrast to those who viewed their characters merely as in-game tools. This indicates that a deeper, more personal investment in the character's narrative and persona is key to unlocking these therapeutic effects, fostering growth in areas such as self-esteem, belonging, and life purpose.

The qualitative data from interviews further illuminated these quantitative findings, particularly highlighting the transformative impact on individuals facing identity challenges, such as queer gamers exploring gender identities. By inhabiting complex fictional roles, players experienced what is termed 'bleed-out,' where insights and emotional lessons from the game seamlessly integrate into their real lives. Caring for their characters and guiding them through fictional adversities empowered players to develop increased empathy and resilience in their own lives, with some even intentionally crafting flawed characters to cultivate self-compassion. Moreover, the enduring nature of long-term gaming campaigns often resulted in profound social continuity, forging lifelong friendships and a strong sense of community, thereby enriching players' lives beyond the game board. However, the study acknowledges the self-reported nature of its data and emphasizes the necessity of cultural familiarity and patient openness for the effective clinical application of TRPGs.

See More